| Opponent | Record | Fixture | Record | Previous Record | |
| N/A | Our Biggest Ever Wins | Round 2, 2011 | Equal 6th in history | N/A | Gold Coast | Record win over Gold Coast | Round 2, 2011 | 119 points | N/A | Gold Coast | Record score against Gold Coast | Round 2, 2011 | 171 points | N/A | Sydney | Losing streak v Sydney in Sydney | Round 6, 2011 | Ended after 18 years | N/A | N/A | Most games in Guernsey #29 - Heath Scotland | Round 7, 2011 | Retired with 215 Carlton games in #29 | 152 - Simon Beaumont | N/A | Most games in Guernsey #46 - David Ellard | Round 6, 2011 | Retired with 63 games in #46 | 9 - John Warden | N/A | Most goals in Guernsey #30 - Jarrad Waite | Round 9, 2011 | Left Carlton in 2015 with 184 games & 252 goals in #30 | 163 - Albert 'Mick' Price | Port Power | Record Winning Streak over Port | Round 11, 2011 | Extended to 5 | 4 | Port Power | Lowest Score against Carlton | Round 11, 2011 | 49 points | 54 points | Richmond | Record score against Richmond | Round 15, 2011 | 184 points | 177 points | Carlton v Hawthorn | Losing streak against the Hawks | Round 22, 2011 | 8* | 7 | N/A | 4 wins in a row | 2011 | Not achieved again for 5 years | N/A |
(Cached)