Round 4, 2012

Carlton 4.4 28 4.7 31 5.12 42 11.13 79 Essendon 3.6 24 8.11 59 12.17 89 15.19 109
Venue:	MCG
Date:	April, 21, 2012 Saturday Afternoon
Result:	Lost by 30 points
Crowd:	73,172
Goalkickers:	E. Betts 4, M. Robinson, J. Garlett, M. Murphy, B. McLean, B. Gibbs, C. Judd, S. Hampson 1.
Reports:
Umpires:	M. Leppard, D. Margetts, B. Rosebury
Injuries:	Carrazzo (shoulder), Laidler (knee), Yarran (toe)
Ladder:	4th

Game Review

Two of the big four in Melbourne matched against each other, both undefeated after three rounds. The promoters couldn't ask for much more. The Blues, having had one of their best wins in recent memory, were riding high on confidence not seen for many years. The Bombers having fallen over the line in a couple of their victories and with more soft tissues injuries than the Kleenex Factory were one of the least favoured undefeated teams I can remember seeing. A healthy crowd was expected and 73,000 fans delivered on those expectations. Now all they needed was a game appropriate for such billing.

A comfortable victory over arch enemy Collingwood meant there was little for the match committee to tinker with at selection given a very solid effort all over the ground. Dennis Armfield was the sole change to the team poised to meet the Bombers. Armfield had wrenched his knee in a collision during round three, but despite soldiering on manfully to finish out the game his knee didn't recover as required and Brock McLean got a chance after three excellent performances in the VFL.

Illustration: http://www.samcrook.com

With a gloomy light cast over proceedings at the MCG at the commencement, it wasn't long before things had turned to doom on the injury front for Carlton. In the opening minute Jeremy Laidler (he of the hideous pre-season dislocated kneecap) seemed to have hurt his poor old knee once again. Down into the rooms he went. Not more than two minutes later Andrew Carazzo followed Laidler's lead into the bowels of the MCG clearly in plenty of pain. His shoulder blade had been cracked in a punishing tackle (of questionable legality) and sadly his day was done. By this stage Laidler had resurfaced from the rooms jabbed up and hobbling around but still standing and battling on. It was an ominous sign. The Bombers got away clearly the better of the two sides. Higher intensity, harder tackles, more speed, more intent all of which lead to the first goal. The Blues responded with a nice end-to-end goal involving lovely long kicks from Michael Jamison and Kade Simpson with a strong Matthew Kreuzer mark and dish in between before Mitch Robinson finished it off with a nice snap. Essendon quickly regained the lead after exposing the Blues over the top of the zone before Carlton got on top for one of the few periods in the match. Three goals came whilst the Blues made hay, first to Jeff Garlett with a well worked snap off the outside of the boot, then came the dodge and weave of Marc Murphy on the left followed by a solid set-shot from Carlton's dominant forward of the first month Eddie Betts. The Bombers kept hanging in there responding late in the quarter to narrow the Carlton lead to a mere four points by the close.

Any ascendency the Blues held disappeared almost instantly upon resumption. An Essendon goal inside two minutes restored their lead and goals would flow steadily to their end throughout the quarter. The Blues had limited opportunities during the term and though Jarrad Waite had been presenting well and marking strongly he was unable to finish when it counted. Same could be said for Simpson who missed a trademark shot on the run from distance which on another day he would have gobbled up. Five unanswered goals from Essendon and a measly three behinds for the Blues spelled a 28 point deficit that would take some turning around.

There was cause for optimism when Betts finally ended the goal drought shortly after half-time goaling from what appeared to be a fortunate free-kick. Sadly that was where it ended. The scorers barely troubled at the Carlton end thereafter but for the odd behind which came from generally wasteful usage. The Bombers seemed more lively over the ground perhaps emphasising the lack of Carlton run after the early injuries to Carrazzo, Laidler and Ed Curnow, the latter two still on field but hobbling noticeably. Essendon added a wasteful 4.6 for the term, perhaps keeping slim hopes alive for the Blues with their inaccuracy, but by the final change held a comfortable 47 point lead.

With the heat appearing to be out of the game the Blues finally got something positive going. An early goal to Betts after a lovely piece of crumbing from a Simpson bomb came with a quick retort from the Bombers, but the Blues battled on. Goals to McLean, Bryce Gibbs, another crumbing effort from Betts (his fourth) and then Chris Judd had reduced the margin to four goals with about eight minutes to play. The patient still had a heartbeat albeit faint. But just as Judd had kept the Blue's hopes alive the Bombers snuffed them out with an instant reply from the next bounce. A late one to either side to finish it out saw the Bombers run out victors by 30 points somewhat flattering the Blues. A reality check for Carlton with a long trip west to meet Freo next task on the list.

Subs: Brock McLean replaced Andrew Carrazzo early in the first quarter

Team

B:	40 Michael Jamison	23 Lachlan Henderson	34 Nick Duigan
HB:	42 Zac Tuohy	15 Jeremy Laidler	13 Chris Yarran
C:	3 Marc Murphy	5 Chris Judd (C)	6 Kade Simpson
HF:	38 Jeffery Garlett	30 Jarrad Waite	9 Kane Lucas
F:	19 Eddie Betts	22 Shaun Hampson	12 Mitch Robinson
Ruck:	8 Matthew Kreuzer	4 Bryce Gibbs	44 Andrew Carrazzo
Interchange:	18 Paul Bower	29 Heath Scotland	35 Ed Curnow
Substitute:	14 Brock McLean
Coach:	Brett Ratten
Emg:	2 Jordan Russell, 16 Andrew Collins, 32 Bret Thornton

Milestones

Interesting Fact: This was the 2,500th VFL/AFL match at the MCG.

Brownlow Votes

3. Brent Stanton, Essendon
2. Jobe Watson, Essendon
1. Stewart Crameri, Essendon

Best & Fairest Votes

Jarrad Waite 34, Kade Simpson 30, Marc Murphy 29, Heath Scotland 26, Eddie Betts 15, Lachie Henderson 13

Ladder

Pos	Team	Plyd	Win	Loss	Draw	For	Agst	%	U/D	Strk	Pts
1	West Coast	4	4	0	0	503	260	193.46	+0	W 4	16
2	Sydney	4	4	0	0	412	278	148.20	+1	W 4	16
3	Essendon	4	4	0	0	429	355	120.85	+1	W 4	16
4	Carlton	4	3	1	0	480	315	152.38	-2	L 1	12
5	Adelaide	4	3	1	0	399	322	123.91	+3	W 1	12
6	Fremantle	4	3	1	0	342	309	110.68	+3	W 2	12
7	St Kilda	4	2	2	0	406	268	151.49	-2	Lt 1	8
8	North Melbourne	4	2	2	0	493	385	128.05	-2	L 1	8
9	Hawthorn	4	2	2	0	413	342	120.76	-2	L 1	8
10	Geelong	4	2	2	0	382	391	97.70	+1	W 1	8
11	Brisbane	4	2	2	0	328	342	95.91	+3	W 1	8
12	Collingwood	4	2	2	0	359	396	90.66	+1	W 1	8
13	Richmond	4	1	3	0	343	359	95.54	-3	L 1	4
14	Port Adelaide	4	1	3	0	331	398	83.17	-2	L 3	4
15	Western Bulldogs	4	1	3	0	191	321	71.91	+0	L 3	0
16	Melbourne	4	0	4	0	210	418	54.74	+1	L 4	0
17	Gold Coast	4	0	4	0	249	492	50.61	-1	L 4	0
18	GWS Giants	4	0	4	0	210	529	39.70	+0	L 4	0

Game	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	11	12
Agst	Rich	Bris	Coll	Ess	Frem	Gws	St.Kilda	Adel	Melb	Port	Geel	W.Cst
Carl	125	154	122	79
Opp	81	63	62	109
Ladder	4	2	2	4
%	154.3	193.7	194.6	152.3
Game	13	14	15	16	17	18	19	20	21	22	23
Agst	BYE	Haw	Coll	N.Melb	W.Bull	Rich	Sydney	Bris	Ess	G.Cst	St.Kilda
Ladder
%

---

Round 3 | Round 5